ive got this acheivement

[Evanescence]

Funny thing actually:

I've been offered Flaming Skins by 3 different Forumers. .

[Evanescence]

alright but i still need to get my ivory if it lets me

Best of luck to you.

[DanTheGamer11]

I know somebody with poor internet that pretty much guarantees a bot match, should I ask for you?

[LambentHammerburst]

This is a known glitch. Only thing you can do is re-earn it (do requirements again).
I'd recommend deleting your profile and recovering it first just to ensure there isn't any corruption.

So delete profile, recover and do requirements again.
This is the only "fix" available right now.